fruitpunch

Business & work ranking

10 Best Payroll Software for Small Business of 2026

By the FruitPunch research deskUpdated November 16, 2026Next review December 31, 2026

The short answer

Gusto is the best payroll software for most small businesses: its Simple plan is $49 a month plus $6 per person with unlimited payroll runs and tax filing, but it only covers one state, so multi-state employers should pick OnPay at the same $49 plus $6 with all 50 states included. Square Payroll is the cheapest full-service option we verified at $35 a month plus $6 per person paid, and Homebase Payroll ($49 plus $6 per active employee) suits shift teams that clock in on a phone. Prices were rechecked on each seller's US page in November 2026; ADP and Paychex quote by phone only.

The podium

  1. 8.6OnPay2
  2. 8.7Gusto1top pick!
  3. 8.5Square Payroll3

Our verdict

Gusto stays on top because $49 a month plus $6 per person buys unlimited payrolls, tax filing, contractor payments and an employee app, and every upgrade price is published. The catch is one state on Simple: the moment you hire in a second state you need Plus at $80 plus $12 per person, and that is where OnPay, with all 50 states at $49 plus $6, becomes the better deal. Square Payroll is the low-cost pick at $35 plus $6 and makes most sense if your staff already clock in on Square. Homebase Payroll is the newcomer on this page: it costs the same as Gusto Simple but runs payroll straight from its own time clock and schedules, with tip pooling listed, which is what restaurants and shops with hourly shifts tend to need. QuickBooks Payroll and Wave Payroll make sense only if you already keep books in those apps. Justworks is for teams that expect to move to a PEO, and Rippling for companies that want payroll on the same record as HR and IT and can wait for a quote. ADP RUN and Paychex Flex bring large service teams, but neither publishes a price, so you cannot compare them until a sales rep calls.

About this ranking

This page is for owners paying a handful to a few dozen people who want a straight answer, not a feature matrix. For each service we name the one limit that usually decides it: how many states it covers, whether you must already use the seller's point of sale or accounting app, or whether the price is published at all. On November 16, 2026 we reopened the pricing and product pages of all 10 services, 12 seller pages in total, and rechecked every price against the US page. Eight prices are published and quoted word for word; ADP and Paychex only give prices on a sales call, so those two are marked pending. Scores weigh quality at 40 percent, ease of use at 25 percent and value at 35 percent. We compared documented features and published prices; we did not run test payrolls. Two mistakes come up again and again. Owners compare the base fee and forget the per-person fee, which is the bigger number past about eight people. And they sign up for a one-state plan before hiring someone who lives across a state line.

Every number, side by side

The taste test

Tap a column to sort. Data from each maker's own pages.

Free plan or trial
1Gusto8.79.08.88.4$49No
2OnPay8.68.48.68.8$4930-day trial
3Square Payroll8.57.88.89.0$35No
4Homebase Payroll8.47.88.88.8$49No
5QuickBooks Payroll8.28.68.47.6$50No
6Justworks8.18.28.27.8$50No
7Rippling8.09.27.67.0$8No
8Wave Payroll7.97.28.28.6$4030-day trial
9RUN Powered by ADP7.88.87.86.6Check priceNo
10Paychex Flex7.68.67.46.6Check priceNo

10 products compared

The full rankings

  1. 1

    Top pick

    Gusto

    8.7out of 10

    Online payroll, benefits and HR for small businesses, with three plans from $49 a month plus $6 per person.

    Best for: Single-state owners who want the most complete $49 plan

    Gusto ranks first because its entry plan already does what most small employers need and the upgrade path is published in full. Simple costs $49 a month plus $6 per person and includes unlimited payrolls, tax filings and payments, direct deposit or printable checks, Payroll on AutoPilot, domestic contractor payments, expenses and reimbursements, and both employer and employee apps. Plus, at $80 plus $12 per person, adds multi-state payroll, time tracking and scheduling, unlimited next-day pay and workforce cost reports. Premium, at $180 plus $22 per person, adds a named advisor, HR guidance and same-day and instant pay. Gusto lists no contracts and free account setup, and health insurance carries no Gusto administration fee. The costs to watch are the add-ons: next-day pay on Simple is $15 a month plus $3 per person, same-day pay is $90 per payroll and state tax registration is priced by state. For a single-state business with a few to a few dozen people, it offers the best balance of features and clear pricing here.

    Gusto is the best payroll software for most small businesses because its $49 Simple plan includes unlimited payrolls, tax filings and contractor payments. Pick OnPay instead if you pay employees in several states.

    What we like

    • No contracts and free account setup, per the pricing page
    • Health insurance offered with no Gusto administration fees
    • Global contractor payments in more than 120 countries as an add-on

    Watch out for

    • Simple covers payroll in one state only
    • Next-day pay on Simple costs $15 a month plus $3 per person
    • Same-day pay costs $90 per payroll below Premium
  2. 2

    Ranked 2

    OnPay

    8.6out of 10

    Full-service payroll with HR, benefits and time tracking add-ons, priced from $49 a month plus $6 per employee.

    Best for: Owners with staff in more than one state

    OnPay is the strongest alternative to Gusto and the better buy for businesses with employees in several states. Its payroll page states that the essentials start at $49 plus $6 per employee per month, and that all 50 states are included without extra cost, where many rivals put multi-state payroll on a higher plan. The base service files federal, state and local taxes automatically, including Forms 941 and 940, processes W-2s and 1099s at year end, allows unlimited pay runs and multiple pay rates, and syncs workers' comp and benefits with payroll. OnPay handles setup and migrates employee data at no charge, and new customers get one month free. Support is listed as unlimited by phone, email and chat. The catch is that HR features like PTO management, custom workflows and document audits sit in a paid HR add-on, and time tracking is another add-on. It ranks just behind Gusto because Gusto bundles more into its upper plans, but at the entry level OnPay gives more for the same price.

    OnPay is the best payroll software for multi-state small businesses because all 50 states are included at $49 a month plus $6 per employee. Pick Gusto instead if you want HR and faster pay bundled into one plan.

    What we like

    • Multi-state payroll at the entry price
    • Unlimited phone, email and chat support
    • Pay workers by direct deposit, check or debit card

    Watch out for

    • PTO management, custom workflows and document audits need the HR add-on
    • Time tracking is a separate add-on
    • HR add-on is $15 base plus $2 per worker, per OnPay's partner price calculator
  3. 3

    Ranked 3

    Square Payroll

    8.5out of 10

    Full-service and contractor-only payroll from Square, connected to Square POS timecards and tips.

    Best for: Shops and cafés already clocking in on Square

    Square Payroll is the cheapest full-service option we verified, at $35 a month plus $6 per person paid, and contractor-only payroll is $6 per person with no base fee. The full-service plan includes unlimited pay runs, auto payroll, off-cycle payments, multistate payroll, multiple pay rates and next-day direct deposit, plus automated federal tax payments and filings. Its edge is the link to Square's point of sale: timecards import from Square POS or the Square Team App, direct tips are tracked and imported, overtime is calculated and labor-cost reporting covers wages and tips. Employees can choose a bank account or Cash App, and free seasonal inactivity helps businesses that close for part of the year. The limits are practical ones. Scheduling reaches only 10 days out, mailed paper tax forms cost $3 each, and without Square POS most of the time and tip features lose their purpose. For a café or salon already on Square, it is the lowest-cost way to get full-service payroll.

    Square Payroll is the best budget payroll software for hourly teams because full-service payroll costs $35 a month plus $6 per person and imports Square POS timecards and tips. Pick OnPay or Gusto if you do not use Square.

    What we like

    • Lowest published full-service base fee on this list at $35
    • Employees can be paid by check, direct deposit or Cash App
    • Free seasonal inactivity for businesses that close part of the year

    Watch out for

    • Scheduling only up to 10 days out
    • Mailed paper W-2s and 1099s cost $3 per form a year
    • Timecard and tip import rely on Square POS or the Square Team App
  4. 4

    Ranked 4

    Homebase Payroll

    8.4out of 10

    Full-service payroll built on Homebase's scheduling and time clock app for hourly teams, $49 a month plus $6 per active employee.

    Best for: Restaurants and shops with hourly shift staff

    Homebase started as a scheduling and time clock app for hourly teams, and its payroll add-on is built on those timesheets rather than on hours typed in by hand. Payroll costs $49 a month plus $6 per active employee, the same as Gusto Simple, and Homebase says you pay only for employees who get paid that month. The payroll page lists automated tax calculation, filing and payment, direct deposit and printable checks, W-2s and 1099s, wage garnishments, tip pooling, next-day payroll and an employee app for pay stubs. It also lists multiple wage rates and blended overtime, which matter for staff who work two roles. The free Basic plan covers scheduling and time tracking for one location with up to 10 employees; paid plans run $30, $70 and $120 per location a month. Limits to know: support runs 7am to 7pm CT rather than around the clock, and several locations can share one payroll run only under the same EIN and pay schedule. If your team works shifts and you do not use Square, this is the simplest way to get hours and payroll in one app.

    Homebase Payroll is the best choice for hourly shift teams outside Square because payroll runs from its own time clock for $49 a month plus $6 per active employee. Pick Gusto if your staff are salaried and you do not need scheduling.

    What we like

    • Same $49 plus $6 price as Gusto Simple with all 50 states and Washington D.C. listed
    • Homebase Basic scheduling and time tracking is $0 for one location up to 10 employees
    • Live human support listed every day from 7am to 7pm CT

    Watch out for

    • Support hours are 7am to 7pm CT, not 24/7
    • Multiple locations share one payroll run only if they have the same EIN and pay schedule
    • Advanced scheduling and team messaging need a paid Homebase plan from $30 per location a month
  5. 5

    Ranked 5

    QuickBooks Payroll

    8.2out of 10

    Intuit's payroll and workforce plans that connect to QuickBooks accounting, sold as Workforce Payroll, Premium and Elite.

    Best for: Owners already keeping books in QuickBooks

    QuickBooks Payroll makes the most sense for businesses whose books already live in QuickBooks, since payroll, HR and bookkeeping are sold as one bundle. The entry Workforce Payroll plan costs $50 a month plus $7 per employee after a 3-month half-price offer. It includes full-service payroll that calculates, files and pays taxes, garnishments and deductions, auto payroll for salaried staff, unlimited 1099 e-filing, an employee portal and next-day direct deposit. Workforce Premium, at $88 plus $13 per employee, adds same-day direct deposit, an expert review of your setup, time tracking, hiring and onboarding, time off management and an HR resource center from Mineral. Workforce Elite, at $134 plus $17 per employee, has an expert set up the account. The trade-off is cost: at $7 per employee the entry plan is the most expensive per head among the verified options here, and time tracking is not included until Premium. It ranks fourth because the features are strong but the price per employee is higher than Gusto, OnPay or Square.

    QuickBooks Payroll is the best choice for QuickBooks accounting users because Workforce Payroll files taxes and syncs with the books from $50 a month plus $7 per employee. Pick Gusto or OnPay if you do not use QuickBooks.

    What we like

    • Payroll support experts by phone and chat
    • Garnishments and deductions set up and calculated per paycheck
    • Employee portal for pay stubs, W-2s and direct deposit details

    Watch out for

    • Highest per-employee fee among verified entry plans at $7
    • Time tracking needs Premium at $88 plus $13 per employee
    • Headline prices show a 3-month discount, so the regular price is easy to miss
  6. 6

    Ranked 6

    Justworks

    8.1out of 10

    Payroll software with HR tools, plus PEO plans that add compliance support and access to health benefits.

    Best for: Small teams that plan to move to a PEO

    Justworks Payroll costs $8 per employee per month plus a $50 base fee and covers more than its entry price suggests. The plan lists payroll for all employees, multi-state payroll, vendor and contractor payments, multiple pay rates, custom payroll periods, off-cycle payments and tips processing, along with employer tax filings and W-2 and 1099 filings. Team tools include online onboarding and offboarding, basic timecards, PTO management, a document center and accounting software integrations. What sets Justworks apart is the upgrade path. PEO Basic, at $79 per employee with no base fee, adds 24/7 support, HR consulting and compliance help, and PEO Plus at $124 per employee adds medical, dental and vision administration and HSA and FSA accounts. Payroll customers can also add access to health insurance for $8 per benefits-eligible employee. For a 10-person team, the payroll plan totals $130 a month, more than Gusto or OnPay, so it ranks fifth on value, but it suits a business expecting to need benefits soon.

    Justworks is the best choice for teams that expect to need a PEO because its $50 plus $8 per employee payroll plan upgrades to PEO Basic at $79 per employee. Pick Gusto if you only need payroll.

    What we like

    • Multi-state payroll included on the $8 per employee plan
    • Phone and chat support listed on every plan
    • Add-on access to medical, dental and vision insurance for $8 per benefits-eligible employee

    Watch out for

    • Highest per-employee fee among verified payroll plans at $8
    • 24/7 support and HR consulting are reserved for PEO plans
    • PEO plans cost $79 to $124 per employee
  7. 7

    Ranked 7

    Rippling

    8.0out of 10

    A modular workforce platform that combines payroll with HR, IT, finance and global hiring products.

    Best for: Growing companies that want payroll, HR and IT on one record

    Rippling has the broadest product range on this list, which is why it scores highest on quality and lowest on value. Payroll is one module among many: the pricing page lists HRIS, recruiting, headcount planning, performance, surveys and learning management on the HR side, global payroll, employer of record and contractor products for international teams, and expense management, corporate cards, bill pay and travel on the finance side. Rippling states that plans start at $8 per employee per month with a monthly base fee, but it does not publish the base fee, and Rippling Payroll itself is priced by custom quote based on headcount and the products you choose. Rippling can import year-to-date payroll data so you can switch mid-year, it integrates with hundreds of third-party apps, and eligible US VC-backed startups can get 6 months free. For a five-person shop that only needs paychecks, this is more system than necessary. For a company hiring quickly that wants payroll, devices, apps and expenses tied to one employee record, it is the strongest platform here.

    Rippling is the best choice for fast-growing teams because payroll sits on one employee record alongside HR, IT and finance modules from $8 per employee. Pick Gusto or OnPay if you want a published all-in payroll price.

    What we like

    • Buy only the modules you need, priced mostly per employee
    • Six months free for eligible US VC-backed startups
    • Mid-year switching with year-to-date payroll import

    Watch out for

    • Payroll price requires a custom quote
    • Base fee amount is not published
    • Per-module prices are not listed on the pricing page
  8. 8

    Ranked 8

    Wave Payroll

    7.9out of 10

    A payroll add-on to Wave's small business accounting software, sold in the US and Canada.

    Best for: Very small businesses already on Wave accounting

    Wave Payroll is a straightforward add-on for businesses already running their books in Wave. In the US it costs a $40 base fee plus $6 per active employee and $6 per independent contractor paid, with no setup fee and a 30-day free trial; these prices apply to customers who signed up after April 2, 2025. Wave automatically transfers tax payments and files the paperwork with your state tax agency and the IRS, though the page notes that 1099 filings are excluded from that service. Direct deposits are unlimited and free, payroll records flow into Wave's accounting software, and employees get a portal for pay stubs, W-2s and vacation leave. Wave also generates W-2, W-3 and 1099-NEC forms. The limits are scope and contractor cost: there are no hiring, onboarding or benefits tools to speak of, and paying contractors costs the same per head as paying employees. For a sole owner with one or two staff on Wave, it is a low-cost fit; growing teams will outgrow it.

    Wave Payroll is the best choice for Wave accounting users because it adds full-service tax filing for $40 a month plus $6 per employee. Pick Square Payroll if you want a lower base fee without Wave.

    What we like

    • No setup fees, per Wave's pricing section
    • 30-day free trial
    • Payroll entries land in Wave's accounting records

    Watch out for

    • Charges $6 for each contractor paid as well as each employee
    • Automated tax service excludes 1099 filings
    • Few HR tools compared with Gusto or Justworks
  9. 9

    Ranked 9

    RUN Powered by ADP

    7.8out of 10

    ADP's payroll and HR platform for businesses with 1 to 49 employees, sold in four packages by quote.

    Best for: Owners who want 24/7 live payroll support

    RUN Powered by ADP is ADP's platform for businesses with 1 to 49 employees, and it has the most structured service ladder on this list. Essential Payroll covers payroll processing, tax filing, automated recurring payroll, desktop and mobile access and 24/7 live payroll support. Enhanced Payroll adds hiring tools with ZipRecruiter, State Unemployment Insurance services, background checks and wage garnishment processing. Complete Payroll & HR+ adds live HR support, an employee handbook wizard, salary benchmarks and HR toolkits, and HR Pro adds access to legal assistance, workplace training, an applicant tracking system from CareerPlug and a learning management system. Add-ons include business insurance, retirement plans, time and scheduling, and a Clover point of sale connection. The problem for a buyer comparing costs is that ADP publishes no prices: each package links to Get Pricing, and the page promotes up to 6 months of free payroll under separate terms. We could not verify a price, so value is scored conservatively, which is why it sits eighth despite strong features.

    RUN Powered by ADP is the best choice for owners who want 24/7 live payroll support and a path to full HR, but it only shares prices through a quote. Pick Gusto or OnPay if you want to compare published prices first.

    What we like

    • Clear package ladder from payroll only to full HR
    • HR Pro adds access to legal assistance and an applicant tracking system
    • Connects with Clover point of sale

    Watch out for

    • No prices published; every package says Get Pricing
    • Promotions such as free months make the true cost harder to compare
    • Hiring tools and garnishment processing need Enhanced or higher
  10. 10

    Ranked 10

    Paychex Flex

    7.6out of 10

    Paychex's payroll and HR software for small businesses, sold in Basic, Foundations, Advanced and Complete plans by quote.

    Best for: Owners who want HR business partners from a large provider

    Paychex Flex is the small business payroll offering from Paychex, which states it serves approximately 840,000 customers. It is sold in four plans: Basic for essential payroll and HR, Foundations adding reporting and HR, Advanced with hands-on support, and Complete with workforce and talent management in one platform. Every plan calculates, withholds and files federal, state and local payroll taxes and produces W-2s and 1099s. Paychex highlights AI automations that flag missing time punches and verify employee data, a configurable payroll dashboard, compliance tracking with alerts, and HR business partners who answer compliance questions. Employees get a 24/7 portal for pay stubs, W-2s and chat support, plus free lifestyle perks. Paychex also now markets Paycor as an acquisition, so mid-size buyers may be steered there. The weakness is price transparency: the page offers Get a Quote and Request Pricing but no figures, so we scored value conservatively and placed it last. It suits owners who want a large provider with human HR help and are willing to negotiate a quote.

    Paychex Flex is the best choice for owners who want HR business partners on call, but prices are quote-only. Pick OnPay or Gusto if a published price matters more than a large service team.

    What we like

    • Paychex HR business partners answer compliance questions
    • Run payroll in as few as two clicks, per Paychex
    • Employee discounts and financial wellness tools at no added cost

    Watch out for

    • No prices published; the page asks you to request a quote
    • Plan prices for Basic, Foundations, Advanced and Complete are not listed
    • The small business payroll page does not say which plan includes the AI time-punch checks

Before you choose

What to check first

  1. 1

    Do the math with your own headcount

    Almost every service charges a base fee plus a fee per person. For 10 people: Square Payroll $95 a month, Wave Payroll $100, Gusto Simple, OnPay and Homebase Payroll $109 each, QuickBooks Workforce Payroll $120 and Justworks Payroll $130. Past about eight people the per-person fee costs more than the base fee, so a $1 difference per head matters more than a $10 difference in base.

  2. 2

    Count the states before you pick a plan

    This is the limit that catches most growing businesses. Gusto Simple runs payroll in one state; multi-state starts on Plus at $80 a month plus $12 per person. OnPay says all 50 states are included without extra cost, Homebase lists all 50 states and Washington D.C., and Justworks lists multi-state payroll on its $8 per employee plan. One remote hire in another state is enough to need it.

  3. 3

    Check what it plugs into

    Square Payroll pulls timecards and tips from Square POS or the Square Team App, and Homebase Payroll runs from its own time clock and schedules. QuickBooks Payroll and Wave Payroll post entries into their own accounting apps. If you use none of these, the integration advantage disappears and Gusto or OnPay are simpler choices.

  4. 4

    Look past the promotion to the regular price

    QuickBooks shows 50 percent off for 3 months, after which Workforce Payroll is $50 plus $7 per employee. Homebase offers 6 months of payroll free with terms, then $49 plus $6. OnPay gives one month free and Wave a 30-day trial. We scored the regular price, because that is what you pay in month seven.

  5. 5

    Know what faster pay and HR add

    Entry plans pay and file taxes; extras cost more. Gusto charges $15 a month plus $3 per person for next-day pay on Simple and $90 per payroll for same-day pay below Premium. OnPay's HR add-on is $15 base plus $2 per worker on its partner calculator. Justworks PEO Basic is $79 per employee with no base fee, which only pays off if you want its benefits and HR support.

FAQ

Questions readers ask

What is the best payroll software for a small business?
Gusto is the best pick for most small businesses in one state. Its Simple plan is $49 a month plus $6 per person and includes unlimited payrolls and tax filing, per its pricing page checked November 16, 2026.
What is the cheapest payroll service for a small business?
Square Payroll is the cheapest full-service option we verified, at $35 a month plus $6 per person paid. If you only pay contractors, Square charges $6 per person with no base fee.
How much does payroll cost for 5 employees?
About $65 to $90 a month on the published plans here. Five people cost $65 on Square Payroll, $70 on Wave Payroll, $79 on Gusto Simple, OnPay or Homebase Payroll, $85 on QuickBooks Workforce Payroll and $90 on Justworks Payroll.
Can I run payroll for employees in different states?
Yes, but not on every entry plan. OnPay includes all 50 states at $49 plus $6 per employee, while Gusto needs its Plus plan at $80 a month plus $12 per person for multi-state payroll.
Is there free payroll software for small business?
No, none of the 10 services here has a permanent free plan for paying employees. Homebase offers 6 months of payroll free with terms, OnPay one month free and Wave Payroll a 30-day trial.
What payroll works best for hourly restaurant or retail staff?
Square Payroll or Homebase Payroll, depending on your time clock. Square imports timecards and tips from Square POS for $35 plus $6 per person; Homebase runs payroll from its own timesheets, with tip pooling, for $49 plus $6 per active employee.
Why do ADP and Paychex not show prices?
Both ask you to request a quote instead of publishing plan prices. RUN Powered by ADP and Paychex Flex pages list packages and features, so we marked their prices pending rather than guess.

How this ranking was scored

Each product gets a 0 to 10 rating on three criteria, and the order follows the weighted total. Ratings rest on each maker's documented features and published prices, not hands-on testing. Read the method.

  • 40%Quality
  • 25%Ease of use
  • 35%Value

Spotted an error or a new price? Write to editorial@fruitpunch.ai. How we work is in our editorial policy. Makers change prices often, so check the seller page before you buy.

Keep browsing

More from the market