fruitpunch

Review · Shopping & services

Firstleaf review

A personalized wine club that picks award-winning bottles from a taste quiz and your ratings, in 6-bottle or 14-bottle boxes.

By the FruitPunch research desk · Updated November 15, 2026

Quality (40%)
8.8
Ease of use (25%)
9.0
Value (35%)
8.6

Firstleaf builds each box from a short taste quiz and then from the ratings you give the wines you receive. It sells 4 plans. The Classic Plan costs $44.95 for the first 6-bottle box with free shipping, then $99 plus shipping per club order, which Firstleaf lists as $16.50 per bottle. Preferred costs $114, Premier $129 and the all Fine Wine plan $159 per 6-bottle order. A 14-bottle order is priced as 12 bottles, and doubled orders add 2 free bonus Fine Wines. Firstleaf puts the minimum retail value of a Classic order at $138 and the average retail price per bottle at $23. Deliveries run every 2 to 12 weeks, you can swap wines before checkout, and members get 30% off in the Firstleaf store. There is no membership fee or cancellation fee. The main catch is that shipping is added to every club order after the first.

Who it is for

Everyday wine drinkers who want picks matched to their taste

Price

Classic Plan: $44.95 intro box with free shipping, then $99 plus shipping per 6-bottle club order ($16.50 per bottle).

Intro: $44.95 + free shipping Club: $99 + shipping
Quoted from the vendor pricing page on November 15, 2026.

Key features

  • 4 plans: Classic, Preferred, Premier and Fine Wine
  • Club orders of 6 bottles, or 14 bottles for the price of 12
  • Deliveries every 2 to 12 weeks, with swaps before checkout
  • Ratings of past bottles shape future recommendations
  • Members get 30% off in the Firstleaf wine store

Strengths and weaknesses

  • Strength: Lowest club price per bottle among the quiz-based clubs: $16.50 on the Classic Plan
  • Strength: No membership fee, long-term contract or cancellation fee
  • Strength: Bottles you dislike are replaced in your next club order
  • Weakness: Club prices exclude shipping, unlike the free-shipping intro box
  • Weakness: The $44.95 intro price applies only to the first box
  • Weakness: Rosé, sparkling and 12x1 options cannot take the 2 free bonus Fine Wines

Key facts

  • Starting price: $99 per 6 bottles plus shipping
  • First box: $44.95 with free shipping
  • Delivery schedule: Every 2 to 12 weeks
  • Average bottle retail price: $23 on the Classic Plan

Where it ranks

Firstleaf is No. 1 in our Best Wine Subscription Clubs verdict.

Alternatives we scored

Visit firstleaf.com · Questions or corrections: editorial@fruitpunch.ai